Young Kafka on Memory and the Insufficiency of Words
At the age of 17, a young Franz Kafka learnt that words are insufficient to name reality.
Words are an odd invention. On the one hand they bring us closer to the world, but, on the other, they evince the gap that separates us from the world. On the one hand they allow us to grasp it and try to comprehend it, and, on the other, they make it obvious that we can only aspire to that: an impression, a trait, the unfinished stroke of an image that escapes us. The world and its representation. Reality and the image we make of it. The thing itself and the word that names it. “In the letters of ‘rose’ is the rose”, reads Borges’ poem, which paraphrases Shakespeare’s, where this skepticism echoes: How far does the power of words go? Could they be less than what we usually attribute to them?
One evening in 1900, a young man came upon this very suspicion. He was seventeen years old and spending the summer in Roztoky, a small city on the edges of eastern Vltava (the river which the Germans call the Moldau), north of Prague. He’d arrived there with his family; all were welcomed by the mail service’s local chief, a man whose last name was Khon. The young man found that Khon’s daughter was almost his own age, which was why —more or less inevitably— many of those days were spent walking together in the nearby forest. During those walks she yearned for him to seduce her, and from one moment to the next dare to touch her; he, without doing the latter, did try the other, but in his own way: reading passages from Thus Spoke Zarathustra out loud, and encouraging the young girl to study and write. Her name was Selma, and his Franz Kafka.
At the time, Kafka read plenty of Nietzsche and, also, began his tortuous itinerary through “the path of women” (Calasso), circumstances in which, after having bid Selma farewell to return to Prague with his family, he wrote the following lines in an album of hers.
To Selma Kohn
[Entry in an album]
How many words in this book.
They are meant for remembrance. As though words could carry memories.
For words are clumsy mountaineers and clumsy miners. Not for them to bring down treasures from the mountains’ peaks, or up from the mountains’ bowels.
But there is a living mindfulness that has passed gently, like a stroking hand, over everything memorable. And when the flame shoots up out of these ashes, hot and glowing, strong and mighty, and you stare into it as though spellbound by its magic, then–
But no one can write himself into this kind of pure mindfulness with unskillful hand and crude pen; one can write only in such white, undemanding pages as these. I did so on September 2, 1900
(Translated by Richard and Clara Winston.)
There is plenty of distance between this Kafka and the merciless Kafka of Zürau’s aphorisms; many years must pass before this young man becomes the tormented writer. And, all in all, the seed of distrust which characterizes part of his literature is there ––That of believing something but being suspicious of it too; graze the world’s mysticism but just to abjure from it and reject it. To trust words and use them to, in the end, denounce their insufficiency. Where are memories the most: in memories themselves or in the words we remember them by?
Perhaps the closest thing to this enigma’s answer is in the fragment of the poem: “In this Night, in this World”, by Alejandra Pizarnik:
do not make love
they make absence
if I say water, will I drink?
if I say bread, will I eat?
Pictorial spiritism (a woman's drawings guided by a spirit)
There are numerous examples in the history of self-taught artists which suggest an interrogation of that which we take for granted within the universe of art. Such was the case with figures like
Astounding fairytale illustrations from Japan
Fairy tales tribal stories— are more than childish tales. Such fictions, the characters of which inhabit our earliest memories, aren’t just literary works with an aesthetic and pleasant purpose. They
A cinematic poem and an ode to water: its rhythms, shapes and textures
Here lies One Whose Name was writ in Water. - John Keats Without water the equation of life, at least life as we know it, would be impossible. A growing hypothesis holds that water, including the
Watch beauty unfold through science in this "ode to a flower" (video)
The study of the microscopic is one of the richest, most aesthetic methods of understanding the world. Lucky is the scientist who, upon seeing something beautiful, is able to see all of the tiny
To invent those we love or to see them as they are? Love in two of the movies' favorite scenes
So much has been said already, of “love” that it’s difficult to add anything, much less something new. It’s possible, though, perhaps because even if you try to pass through the sieve of all our
This app allows you to find and preserve ancient typographies
Most people, even those who are far removed from the world of design, are familiar with some type of typography and its ability to transform any text, help out dyslexics or stretch an eight page paper
The secrets of the mind-body connection
For decades medical research has recognized the existence of the placebo effect — in which the assumption that a medication will help produces actual physical improvements. In addition to this, a
The sea as infinite laboratory
Much of our thinking on the shape of the world and the universe derives from the way scientists and artists have approached these topics over time. Our fascination with the mysteries of the
Sharing and collaborating - natural movements of the creative being
We might sometimes think that artistic or creative activity is, in essence, individualistic. The Genesis of Judeo-Christian tradition portrays a God whose decision to create the world is as vehement
John Malkovich becomes David Lynch (and other characters)
John Malkovich and David Lynch are, respectively, the actor and film director who’ve implicitly or explicitly addressed the issues of identity and its porous barriers through numerous projects. Now